For whom the bell
tolls?
No-one can say they don’t know how to make
period dramas in England. They are wonderful at it and they do it a LOT! I feel
at least 80% of the British shows I’ve seen over the years have been period
dramas. I’d have to conclude almost all of them are “good”, but they rarely
feel “ground-breaking”.
There are millions of period dramas to choose
from in UK TV, so it is hard to decide which one to watch next. Lately, I am
becoming more and more attached to Channel 4 programs, especially since I
discovered my new obsession Utopia; which is the main reason I decided to give The Mill a chance [it was also nominated for a BAFTA].
The Mill tells the story of the workers of Quarry
Bank Mill in Chesire, England. It serves as a historical drama, dealing with
the changes in labour laws throughout the industrial revolution; but it is also
a character driven show. In fact, I think the strongest aspects of the show are
not the historical components but the relationships and personal drama.
There are many things about this show that felt
refreshing. It’s not about an epic romance or a major event; it’s about common working-class
people. Don’t get me wrong; I love Downton
Abbey, as much as the next TV fan, but sometimes it feels like we spend too
much time on the rich.
Above all I loved the characters on The Mill. They are nowhere near the
usual clichés of period dramas. The leading character, Esther Price, is full of
exciting contradictions. I appreciate that they avoided making her the typical “victim”
in an abusive environment. She is sassy, independent, headstrong and sometimes
reckless. She’s like the Veronica Mars of
the 19th century [that’s probably a comparison you will never hear
from your average period drama viewer!]
The first episode has Esther facing the threat
of being raped by one of the mill’s overlookers. Esther does what no-one seems
to do in historical dramas and she starts accusing the man left and right. When
no-one pays attention to her claims, she takes matters into her own hands,
steals a bell’s clapper and hits the man in the head when he was about to take
advantage of her. And the story continues like this. The writers didn’t fall into
the trap of making Esther a “pristine” character either. They kept her
personality consistent with her social standing (For instance, she has a child
out of wedlock). The rest of the characters aren’t as colourful or original,
but they are still compelling.
In summary, after watching my share of period
dramas, I think they managed to give the genre some edge with The Mill.
Should you watch it? Not “must watch” TV [unlike Utopia] but quite enjoyable, especially if you
love period pieces.
0 comments:
Post a Comment
Add your Comment Here